How to split a bill fairly

A short guide to the two common ways a group splits a check, and how to keep tax and tip fair when everyone ordered something different.

See it in action

The recording above splits a small lunch between Ana and Ben. It follows the same five steps you'll see in the split-by-item calculator:

  1. Items. Add each line from the receipt with its price. Here that's a burger at $14.50, fries at $5.00 and a salad at $12.00.
  2. Tax and tip. Type the two amounts from the bill, $3.00 tax and $7.50 tip in this example.
  3. Who's here. Add a name for everyone at the table.
  4. Assign. Tap an item, then tap each person who shared it. The burger goes to Ana, the salad to Ben, and the fries to both, so each of them carries half of that $5.00.
  5. Who owes what. Ana owes $22.67 and Ben owes $19.33. Together that's $42.00, the same as the items, tax and tip on the bill.

You can check the result by hand. Ana's items come to $17.00 (the burger plus half the fries) and Ben's to $14.50 (the salad plus half the fries), a subtotal of $31.50. Ana's share of that is about 54 percent, so she covers about 54 percent of the $3.00 tax and $7.50 tip, which is $1.62 and $4.05.

Splitting evenly vs. splitting by item

There are really only two approaches to splitting a bill, and the right one depends on what the group ordered. Splitting evenly means dividing the total by the number of people. It works well when everyone ordered roughly the same amount, such as a group of friends who each got an entrée and a drink. It's fast and nobody has to itemize anything.

Splitting by item is fairer when orders were uneven, for example if one person had an appetizer and a soda while another had three courses and two cocktails. Itemizing means each person pays for roughly what they actually consumed, plus a fair share of tax and tip, instead of subsidizing someone else's order.

Handling shared items

Shared plates are the trickiest part of splitting by item. The fairest approach is to divide a shared item's cost evenly across everyone who ate it. A $24 appetizer split three ways is $8 each, rather than being assigned to whoever happened to order it. In EasyBillSplitting's split-by-item mode, you can drag one item onto multiple people, and it automatically divides that item's price evenly across everyone it's assigned to.

Dividing tax and tip fairly

Once each person's item subtotal is known, tax and tip should generally scale with how much each person ordered rather than being split evenly across the group. Someone who ordered $60 of food should pay more of the tax and tip than someone who ordered $15. This is called a proportional split, and it's the default in most bill-splitting tools, including this one.

There's a reasonable exception. Some groups prefer to split tip evenly regardless of order size, treating service as something the whole table benefited from equally. Both approaches are common, and the choice really comes down to group preference, which is why the results screen lets you toggle between proportional and even tip splitting after the numbers are in.

Applying discounts and coupons

A discount that applies to the whole order, such as a happy-hour percentage off or a coupon, should come off the subtotal before tax and tip are calculated, allocated proportionally across everyone based on what they ordered. A discount that applies to one person only, such as a birthday freebie or a loyalty reward, should come off that person's final total instead. Keeping these two cases separate is what prevents a group discount from being absorbed by just one person, or a personal discount from quietly reducing everyone else's share too.

A quick worked example

Say three friends split a bill. Person A ordered $30 of food, Person B ordered $20, and they shared a $12 appetizer evenly. Item subtotals become A: $36 ($30 plus $6 shared), B: $26 ($20 plus $6 shared). With $5 tax and $10 tip split proportionally, A (about 58% of the subtotal) pays roughly $2.90 tax and $5.80 tip, and B pays the rest. Each person pays tax and tip in proportion to what they actually ordered, instead of an even split that would overcharge the person who ordered less.

Ready to run the numbers on an actual bill? Use the calculator, or check the FAQ for edge cases like unassigned items and even-split discounts.