Should you split the tip evenly or in proportion?

Nobody argues about the pasta. It's the tip that gets people tight-lipped. You can agree on every line of the check and still end up in a standoff over whether the tip gets divided by head count or by who ate what.

Even versus proportional

Even is the lazy version: add up the tip, divide by the number of people, done. Proportional ties each person's tip to their own food, so if you ordered 40 percent of everything on the table you cover 40 percent of the tip.

Most people expect proportional without ever saying so, since tips are a percentage to begin with. Tip 20 percent on your own meal and the group's total is identical to a proportional split. Go even and somebody is quietly subsidizing somebody else. Usually it's the person who stuck to a salad.

Try it with numbers

Say four of you get a 140 dollar check. Ana's food and drinks came to 60, Ben's to 40, Cara's to 25 and Dev's to 15. You settle on 20 percent, so 28 dollars of tip.

Even split: everyone puts in 7. That's fine for Ana, who's tipping about 12 percent of her own order. Dev ordered a 15 dollar meal and just tipped 47 percent on it.

Proportional: Ana pays 12, Ben 8, Cara 5, Dev 3. Each of them has tipped exactly 20 percent of what they ordered, which is why this is the version that rarely starts a fight. It's also what EasyBillSplitting does by default, though there's a checkbox if you'd rather go even.

When even is the right call

If everyone's order landed within a few dollars of each other, the two methods give nearly the same answer, so take the easy one. Even also makes sense when someone's being treated, or when the table has an informal deal that you take turns covering things.

It's kinder to the person who skipped drinks to save money, too. The server still walked to the table for them just as often.

Settling it in ten seconds

Ask before the check shows up, because it's much harder to raise afterward. Something like "evenly or by what we ordered?" is plenty. A rough rule: if the biggest order is less than about 30 percent above the smallest, go even. Beyond that, go proportional.

Pick the percentage first and the method second. Arguing about the rate is arguing about values. Arguing about the method is arithmetic. They're easier to solve one at a time.

Before or after tax?

Plenty of people tip on the pre-tax subtotal, since the tax isn't going to the server. Others tip on the final total because it's quicker. You're talking about a point or two of difference on the tip itself, so don't lose sleep over it. Just make sure the whole table is doing the same thing. EasyBillSplitting asks for the tip as an amount, so use whichever you like.

The same bill with tax included

Take the four friends again, but now the check shows a 140 dollar subtotal and 11.20 in tax (8 percent). If the group tips 20 percent on the pre-tax subtotal, the tip is 28 dollars. If it tips on the final total of 151.20, the tip is 30.24. That's a 2.24 dollar gap across the whole table, which works out to about 56 cents each if you split it evenly.

Proportional shares give Ana 60 of 140, so she covers 42.9 percent of the tip. On the pre-tax tip that's 12.00. On the after-tax tip it's 12.96. Whichever base you choose, apply it to everyone at the table and the total stays consistent.

A mental check before you pay

Divide the tip by the pre-tax subtotal. If you get a number near the percentage you meant to leave, you're fine. In the example, 28 divided by 140 is 0.20, exactly 20 percent. If a proportional split gives somebody a personal tip rate far from the group's, one of the figures was probably typed wrong.

This is also a useful sanity test when somebody else did the math. Add up everyone's tip share. It should equal the total tip to the cent, give or take a rounding difference of a penny or two.

Rounding without a fight

Proportional shares rarely land on whole cents. Twelve dollars and ninety-six cents is easy, but 9.4286 isn't. Round each person to the nearest cent and, if the total is a cent or two off, let the person who's paying the card absorb it. Arguing over a single cent costs more goodwill than it saves.

Ready to try it? Split a bill now.

More guides